NATO warns Europe’s jet fuel crunch could cap airpower in high-intensity war

A NATO-backed study warns Europe’s shrinking refining base could leave NATO air forces short of jet fuel in an Article 5 war, constraining sortie generation from the mid-2030s.

Share
NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte visiting soldiers at a military facility in Münster, Germany.
NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte visiting soldiers at a military facility in Münster, Germany.

Key facts

  • NATO-backed ENSEC COE study warns jet fuel shortages could constrain NATO air operations in a major Article 5 war scenario.
  • Study models a “reasonable worst case” with significant North American deployment and finds that from the mid-2030s civil restrictions alone may not balance fuel supply and demand.
  • Europe’s refining contraction is cited as a driver: roughly a quarter of refineries have shut since 2009, leaving around 70 operational plants supplying domestic jet fuel.

3 minute read

A NATO-backed study by the NATO Energy Security Centre of Excellence (ENSEC COE) argues that NATO Europe could face binding jet fuel constraints in a future high-intensity conflict, as the continent’s decarbonisation trajectory intersects with a long-term contraction in oil refining capacity. The report, circulated at senior levels within the alliance according to ENSEC COE, frames the risk as operational rather than abstract: in a major war involving European members and substantial North American reinforcement, aircraft fuel demand could overwhelm supply, potentially limiting sortie rates irrespective of platform and weapons availability.

The analysis is explicitly tied to a “reasonable worst case” model of a full-scale conflict in NATO Europe triggered by Article 5, with significant transatlantic deployment. It concludes that, from the mid-2030s, “no quantity of civil restrictions balances the system… without intervention,” indicating that traditional crisis measures such as prioritisation or rationing may be insufficient. The study further states that even complete requisition of civilian jet fuel would not close the gap, estimating 4.7 million tonnes of jet fuel unmet from 2035, with the shortfall expanding sharply thereafter.

The report links vulnerability to a shrinking European refining base. Cited FuelsEurope and European Commission data indicate roughly a quarter of Europe’s oil refineries have closed since 2009, with Europe left with around 70 operational plants capable of supplying domestic jet fuel. This is presented as a structural readiness issue: fuel production capacity, stockpiling options and the resilience of intra-European distribution become critical enablers for airpower generation, particularly under hybrid pressure and sabotage risks that have already heightened concern about direct confrontation with Russia.

For Europe, the immediate implication is that defence spending on aircraft, munitions and drones may not translate into sustainable combat power unless fuel supply security is treated as a core element of deterrence. The study recommends preserving refining capacity, expanding strategic reserves, diversifying imports, accelerating alternative aviation fuels to add supply, and improving military fuel efficiency. While ENSEC COE stresses the findings are independent rather than formal NATO policy, the report’s prominence—and public remarks cited from NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte acknowledging concern over Europe’s lack of refineries in a Russia contingency—signals that energy and fuel logistics are moving toward the centre of alliance readiness planning.

Source: Politico Europe